Reflections on life at “De Witte Wand”…

The Levers That Power Cults

A couple of days ago, I mentioned a couple of thought-provoking articles in the current issue of Prospect. The first looking at the background to  the lead bomber of 7/7, and the second that highlighted the views of Mary Douglas on cults.
 
In the comments to my entry, Coboró mentioned that he had found that the quotation from the article on Mary Douglas fitted the situation of Fred Phelps’ Westboro Baptist Church "chillingly".
 
I have to say that I’m not surprised. The laws that determine whether cults succeed or fail seem fairly straightfoward. What is depressing is how often the victims fail to appreciate this.
 
But today, I came across another blog posting that I found illuminating. It’s from Sean Prophet, who writes the Black Sun Journal blog. Sean grew up in a cult – his parents founded the Summit Lighthouse.
 
And why did I find Sean’s posting illuminating? Because it makes the all-too-obvious-point-in-hindsight that cults derive their power not only from their leaders, but also from their persuaded followers. Well, hindsight may be a wonderful thing, but Sean’s point is nonetheless valid for that. And he provides a very useful checklist for identifying cults:
What do all cults have in common, to varying degrees?
  1. A strong central leader or founder.
  2. Belief that the leader has access to special and exclusive information or has special authority. (In the case of financial cults, it’s the illusion the leader provides of freedom from the laws of economics. The “mark” is vulnerable because of their desire for a quick buck.)
  3. A demand for loyalty oaths and obedience.
  4. High initiation fee or other renunciative action geared toward making withdrawal difficult, such as a requirement to cut off contact from one’s family.
  5. Rings and rising levels of membership, which reward strong commitment.
  6. Intensive, often confrontational–yet uncommonly intimate social relationships.
  7. Reinforcement of in-group and out-group differences. External threats actually benefit the cult by amplifying and solidifying interior control.
  8. Make people feel special, loved, and accepted.
  9. Often attract lonely or confused people who need direction and may have trouble fitting into typical career paths.
But the most important characteristic of cults, without which they could not exist is:
 
THEY NEED MEMBERS
 
Members provide the power. They are the cult’s life blood.
 
Without members, a cult leader would be just another delusional nutjob or con man. Without followers, the leaders’ loyalty demands or financial claims would sound downright creepy or fraudulent. Their wacky extremist philosophies would be seen in the same category as a homeless person shouting on the street corner. Early members provide the opportunity to hone and polish a more skilled presentation, develop wider legitimacy, and an illusion of popular support to budding sociopaths.
The first thing a burgeoning cult leader has to do is:
  1. Create a mythology or backstory. In the financial cult, it’s fake case histories and success stories.
  2. Create a mission to give the work a sense of exclusivity and desirability (the way Tom Sawyer got the other boys to paint the fence). Establish an inner circle willing to reinforce their authority (at least until the membership grows).
  3. Acquire the skills to fend off challengers (as soon as members of the inner circle see the power or money start to flow, they will begin vying for it).
Most people don’t have the skills to manage a relationship with even one other person. We only have to look to the high divorce rate to verify this fact. Imagine what it’s like for a leader to meet daily challenges to his authority (without the normal reward/punishment system of money/loss of job). This is why a cult leader has to get used to saying “because I said so” with a straight face. He has to get used to doling out stern summary justice in the form of ostracism and outright dismissal. He has to learn to use member peer pressure to humiliate and corral troublemakers. It also helps to appeal to supernatural beings and endless divine missions. But it’s not absolutely necessary. The most important skill is an uncommon ability to connect with people (on whatever terms), and to attract and control members.  
So a strong leader is the catalyst, but as Sean so rightly says: MEMBERS PROVIDE THE POWER. Read the rest of his post. It’s worth it.
 

Leave a comment