Reflections on life at “De Witte Wand”…

Struck Speechless

So, I’m reading a blog entry over at Counterknowledge.com written by Matthew Hartfield. He’s looking at the correlation between the rising outbreaks of measles and the anti-vaccination scare caused by baseless fears that the MMR vaccine was linked to autism. Not unexpectedly, the UK has seen large outbreaks of measles as a result.
 
But he also looks at the situation in other European countries that have seen outbreaks of measles, notably Switzerland and Austria. And here, he finds an interesting connection with Anthroposophy, developed by "mystic and social philosopher" Rudolf Steiner. His ideas live on in Waldorf/Steiner schools. Some of those ideas might be beneficial to child development, but some are clearly dangerous woo. For example:
Waldorf’s official position on immunization is that there is no official Waldorf position on immunization. Instead, Waldorf says that immunization should be informed by medical professionals, and ultimately parents should decide whether or not to immunize their own children.
 
Typically Waldorf schools do not encourage parents to immunize their children against the following diseases: Hepatitis B; Diphtheria, Tetanus, Pertussis; Haemophilus influenzae Type b; Inactivated Polio; Measles, Mumps, Rubella; Varicella and Pneumococcal Conjugate Vaccine (PCV).
So what if your child falls ill, or even dies as a result of a preventable disease?
Don’t be alarmed if your child dies from a preventable disease because he/she is not immunized, it was probably their destiny. It clearly wasn’t their destiny to be immunized.
Hartfield writes: "I’m genuinely speechless". So am I. It’s appalling.

3 responses to “Struck Speechless”

  1. Sarah Avatar
    Sarah

    Hi. I think there’s a great deal of anthroposophy that they keep hidden; the education certainly needs to be investigated.Did you see this article at counterknowledge as well?http://counterknowledge.com/2009/01/origin-of-the-specious-race-lies-and-stereotypes-in-steiner%E2%80%99s-anthroposophy/The comments are very revealing.Also this sitehttp://www.waldorfcritics.org/active/articles.htmltjhe articles are hair reaisingand herehttp://www.waldorf-problems.com/The schools are very secretive that the education is rooted in this strange cult like occult science.And they’ve just got state funding for an academy in Hereford- millions of government funding, and are looking for more….Struck speechless indeed!

  2. Geoff Avatar
    Geoff

    Sarah, thanks for those links. It may well be that some Steiner schools do proper education, but I am starting to wonder whether they are the exception rather than the rule. Steiner was clearly a sandwich or three short of a proper lunch, and it’s distressing to realise that his misbegotten baby has not been thrown out with the bathwater after all this time. I will henceforth look upon evidence of gnomes in schools with newly-awakened eyes… But, to be serious, this is no way to educate children.

  3. Sarah Avatar
    Sarah

    Hi Geoff, yes I think you’ve hit the nail on the head about the exceptions to the rule. I tend to think that because the Steiner definition of "education" veers wildly from what even the most radical among us would understand; for instance, they believe that stimulating the intellect before the age of 14 "damages the astral body"; so the children, rather than being encouraged to ask, question, and be creative, are directed to be the very opposite. To copy the teacher’s writing into their books, to copy their wet watery paintings, where they’re given limited colour palates.This is the antithisis of what prospective parents are lead to believe the schools are.And the reasons for these ways are… beyond reason! Spiritual worlds, incarnation, Atlantis, karma.Fascinating, but terrifying that this huge organisation, schools, biodynamic agriculture, camphill and weleda, dr. hauschka, has managed to propogate their movement while hiding it’s central tenets.

Leave a comment